Fat Boys

Fat Boys in New Waterford is a familiar kind of local eatery where the welcome is as warm as the ovens baking their thin crust pizzas. Stepping inside, you quickly settle into a space that balances old-school charm with the quiet buzz of a neighborhood hub—a place where time slows just enough to savor simple, well-loved flavors without fuss. There’s an easygoing rhythm here, the kind that feels natural whether you’re grabbing a quick slice after work or lingering over a casual meal with friends or family.

The air carries the comfort of melted cheese and crisped crusts, inviting you to explore familiar favorites with a subtle twist—like a donair-topped pie that speaks to local tastes with a nod to tradition. The atmosphere hums with quiet conversations and the occasional sizzle from the kitchen, offering a grounded, everyday kind of joy that resonates in this close-knit community.

Fat Boys isn’t just about pizza; it’s a place where shared moments unfold—whether over a plate of crispy garlic fingers that pair perfectly with a cold drink, or a bowl of poutine that feels like a warm hug on a chilly evening. You can sense the care in the way the new owners have preserved the heart of a local favorite while inviting a slightly fresher energy into the space.

Here, the pace is casual and friendly, reflective of New Waterford itself, a town where familiarity runs deep and delicious food serves as a quiet centerpiece for connection. Fat Boys may close earlier than the night’s late crowd might wish, but while open, it offers a dependable retreat—a place where generations find comfort in taste and atmosphere alike.